Thursday 23 May 2013

Penguin 2.0 Losers: Porn Sites, Game Sites, & Big Brands Like Dish.com & The Salvation Army

Google’s fourth Penguin update — what the company is calling Penguin 2.0 — hit last night, and less than 24 hours later we’re already getting a first chance to look at what sites might be considered “losers” in terms of search visibility.
 angry-penguin-200px
In a nutshell, the list includes: porn sites, game sites and big brands like Dish.com, the Salvation Army, CheapOair and Educational Testing Service (yes, ETS, the company that makes a lot of those standardized tests you probably took as a child).

The SEO software company, SearchMetrics, has just shared its initial look at what sites have been affected the most by the latest Penguin update. As always, SearchMetrics is using its “SEO Visibility” benchmark, which looks at the visibility of a company’s web pages as they appear (or don’t appear) across a wide range of keywords in Google’s search results.

Here’s their initial list of the 25 biggest Penguin 2.0 losers:
penguin-losers-searchmetrics
There are eight porn sites on the list of 25, and four game-related sites. Of those game sites, three are listed in the top 10. (You have to merge the porn sites listed at the bottom with the sites above them to get the actual order of impact.)

There are also several well-known brands, like Dish.com, the Salvation Army, ETS, and CheapOair. REEDS jewelers has been around since 1946 and has stores in 18 states. DailyDot.com, also on the list, is a respected online news site.

The column on the far right shows how much “SEO Visibility” each website has lost — at least for the keywords that SearchMetrics tracks. This doesn’t necessarily mean that these websites are all seeing dramatic traffic losses, because they might still have high visibility for keywords that aren’t being tracked. That said, in the couple years that we’ve been reporting on the Penguin and Panda updates, lists from SearchMetrics and a couple other SEO software companies have generally been considered mostly accurate.
In his blog post, SearchMetrics founder Marcus Tober says the impact from this latest Penguin update is smaller than he expected.
It’s not the update I was expecting. I thought that this Googles Penguin update would have had a bigger impact similar to Panda 1. But that didn’t happen. My first analysis shows that many thin sites, sites with thin links and especially untrusted links face the problem. In addition, some small business sites were hit because they haven’t taken SEO serious enough.
He also told us via email that the impact was much stronger in Germany than in the U.S., and SearchMetrics details some of the Penguin-hit websites in Germany in a separate blog post (German language).

Monday 20 May 2013

SEO Website Audits: Penguin, Panda, Technical

With Google constantly changing their algorithm to eliminate low quality content (Panda Update), sites with structures or metrics that don’t support their large content or product sets or sites that try to manipulate the search results with link schemes or other manipulative tactics (Penguin Update), it is vitally important to do website audits on a regular basis. These audits, much like getting a yearly checkup at your doctor (to combat health issues), can eliminate or minimize the effect of the Google updates on a poorly optimized or site that is not in good health.

To learn more about some of the questions and data points for SEO Audit Process -

1. SEO Technical Analysis -

This analysis will help identify technical (metrics distribution) problems with your website such as duplicate title tags, duplicate content, or if your web pages are returning an incorrect HTTP status code. Below are some more of the data points we check from a technical standpoint to ensure your site is healthy.
  • 301 (Permanent) Redirect Analysis
  • 302 (Temporary) Redirect Analysis
  • 404 (Client Error) Errors
  • 500 (Server Error) Errors
  • Pages Where The Title is Missing or Empty
  • Duplicate Page Content Analysis
  • Duplicate Page Title Analysis
  • Pages That have Long URLs (> 115 characters)
  • Overly-Dynamic URL Analysis
  • Meta Refresh Analysis
  • Pages Where the Title Element is Too Short
  • Pages Where the Title Element is Too Long (> 70 Characters)
  • Pages Containing Too Many On-Page Links
  • Missing Meta Description Tag Analysis
  • Robots.txt Analysis
  • Meta-robots Nofollow Analysis
  • Meta-robots Analysis
  • Canonical Tags Analysis
  • Indexed URLs Analysis
  • Total URLs Receiving Traffic
  • Total Keywords Sending Traffic

2. Content Analysis and Panda Audit

Quality content is one of the primary assets your website has when it comes to competing in the search engines for rankings. We conduct the 4 major audits listed below.
  • Panda Update Analysis
  • Duplicate Content Analysis
  • Keyword Analysis
We recently added the Panda Update Analysis after the recent launch of the Panda Update to the Google Algorithm. This analysis combs over your content sets and asks a set of questions to assess the quality and value your content provides. This audit assess if our content is at risk of being devalued by the search engines and caught in the Panda Update. A few of the questions we ask are listed below.
  • Would you trust the information presented here?
  • Does this article have obvious errors?
  • Does this article provide additional information beyond what others are saying, and does it present it in a unique way.
  • Does this article contain insightful analysis?
  • Is this article written by an expert?
  • Would you expect to see this article in print?
  • Would you give this site your credit card?
  • Would you trust medical (replace medical information with your vertical’s information) information from this site.

3. Competitive, Link Analysis and Penguin Update Analysis

This is one of the most important audits for your site since it will uncover keyword ranking issues, possible issues that caused your site to get penalized with the Penguin (Over-optimization) penalty, and who your true online competitive is within the search engines organic search results.
  • Identify low value links pointing to your website
  • Real Online Competition (usually not who you think)
  • Keyword Competition
  • Competitive Link Audit
  • Export of Your Competitions Link Graph
  • Competitive Keyword Difficulty Audit

4. Site Architecture Analysis

The marketing campaigns you are running will drive people to link to your website and share it socially. Your site acquires links, link juice, and social metrics from these campaigns and distributes those metrics internally though the site’s link structure. After we assess the technical parts of your website we want to also make sure that your websites architecture is valuable for metrics distribution.
  • Structural Analysis
  • Page Rank Flow Analysis
  • Internal Anchor Text Analysis